Friday, January 3, 2014

The Sentry Commentary by Sonali Gil

“The Sentry” by Wilfred Owen (Class Presentation Essay)
The poem is structured into three stanzas; the first describes the external environment, the second explains the encounter with the sentry and the third sees the poet grieving for the sentry while introspecting. Thus it progresses from external to internal conflict. As suggested by its concluding lines “"I see your lights!" But ours had long died out” the poem has an initially grim, dark tone which transforms into one of hopeless despair. A reference is made to loss of hope in the line “ours (light) had long died out”.  The poet strives to create a distraught, violent mood which reflects the war going on by using diction such as “shell on frantic shell”, “fumes of whizz-bangs”, “their curse” and “dredged him up”. He specifically uses personifications, which can be considered hyperboles, while describing the conditions inside the trench, the position of his regiment and the way in which he discovers the sentry. One can consider examples such as the phrases “rain, guttering down in waterfalls”, “wild chattering”, “shrieking air” and “deluging muck”.
In the first stanza we are introduced to Owen and his men in “den”, [1]where they have just encountered “an old Bauche”. [2]Interestingly the poet uses a German soldier, who gives his regiment “shell on frantic shell” to introduce the poem which he later juxtaposes with the pathetic condition in which the British sentry is found. This is the first instance in the poem where juxtaposition is used; Owen contrasts weakness and surrender with strength and resistance. Notably this recurs throughout the poem; juxtapositions between dreams and nightmares, hope and despair are made. These can be treated as important psychological aspects of the war, as well as physical. It is important to note that Owen speaks for all soldiers (including the enemy) while referring to “those other wretches” who “left there curse in the den”. This is further indicated by his use of sequential use of pronouns (“us”, “their”, “he”, “I”) which strengthen the progression from external to internal conflict.
An important, unique feature of this poem is the use of slang words. On two occasions Owen uses the word “Bauche” which was WWI British slang referring to the Germans and on one occasion he calls shells “crumps”. Furthermore the sentence structure of the poem is fragmented throughout; perhaps indicative of the “shocked” mental state the poet was in while writing it. The reader is exposed to sentenced like “shell upon frantic shell, Hammered on top, but never quite burst through” where the poet uses the capitalized “H” to begin a new sentence. Such a sentence structure recurs across his poetry as does the poem’s rhyme scheme which is also thoroughly disjointed. This reader believes that an ABC rhyme scheme is followed as suggested by first seven sentences’ concluding words “knew”, “shell”, “through” “slime”, “hour”, “climb” and “sour”. Frequently used internal rhymes such as “gave us hell, shell on frantic shell”, “thud! flump! thud!” and “mud in ruck on ruck” add to the fragmented sentence structure and highlight the use of auditory imagery.
This poem has a blend of all types of imagery which the poet uses to create and enhance the atmosphere. Owen uses olfactory imagery to create the setting around him writing about the “smell of men” which can also be seen as indicative of how much time they have spent in the trenches. He refers to “rain, guttering down in waterfalls of slime” which is an example of both visual and auditory imagery. Perhaps the most horrific use of visual imagery is when Owen describes the physical condition of the sentry: “Eyeballs, huge-bulged like squids” which leaves a gruesome image in the reader’s mind. Incidentally, the sentry who Owen met went blind too. Owen uses many words such as “shell”, “steps”, “slime” and “steep” to create sibilance. There is also casual reference to nightmares which “watch my dreams still’ which the poet was also being treated for at Craiglockhart. It can be said that Owen uses horrific imagery to gradually develop the feeling tragedy and guilt.
Guilt and internal conflict are the primary sub-themes evolved in the poem. Owen’s literary critics have suggested he uses the setting of a secluded trench, against the backdrop of and external war to enhance the reader’s perception of internal conflict. The line “The sentry's body; then his rifle, handles Of Bauche bombs” emphasize the slow speed at which the body comes into view and to the reader is resembles the image of plunging a dagger into a heart and slowly pulling it out. Moreover it gives both Owen and the reader time to process the horrors of war and the guilt which begins to settle onto Owen’s heart. It is when the poet is trying to comfort the soldier that his guilt is most evident; he tells the soldier that he is not actually blind if he can see a flicker of light. This shows the medical negligence of the time and Owen’s desperate desire to appease his conscience. There is a touch of cruel irony in the lines “Eyeballs, huge-bulged like squids, Watch my dreams still; but I forgot him there, In posting next for duty, and sending a scout, To beg a stretcher somewhere, and floundering about, To other posts under the shrieking air” because it indicates that though the experience left the poet “floundering about”, he wishes to forget the incident.
“The Sentry” is unique in some respects, such as language, as highlighted above yet it resembles many of Owens’s other poems both thematically and linguistically. For example, he uses nightmares and disillusionment similarly in his poem “Dulce Et Decorum Est”. It aims to highlight the internal conflict faced by human beings in the face of a larger external conflict. Like in his poem “Insensibility”, he refers to all kinds of soldier however choosing to create a divide between enemy and friend instead of the various ranks of an army. He defines the susceptibility and dependence of human cruelty on circumstance which is highlighted by the difference in reaction to the condition of the British and German soldiers. Owen also highlights how emotional investment can lead to massive guilt by using his own example; literary critics have suggested that he felt personally guilty at the sentry’s death because as a Junior Officer he was responsible for deploying sentries at the front. In conclusion, “The Sentry” explores the nuances of human condition while highlighting its frailty, the worst of which is brought out, according to the poet, by “the pity of war”.







[1] Owen is referring to a trench                                                                                                                                                        
[2] British slang for a German soldier

No comments:

Post a Comment

Please add your comments below

How to win and to lose on the same day.

 March 30th 2023 I have had my flat- an immaculately refurbished one bedroomed 2nd floor, not very special but servicable space in Pool. Red...